This edition is brought to you by our friends at uSERP.

Quick math on what organic search is worth when it actually works:

Monday.com doubled organic traffic to 1.2M visits before their IPO. Earlybird drove 20,000+ acquired users before getting bought by Acorns. OnBoard tripled their organic pipeline value in a single year.

All three worked with uSERP.

The difference between agencies that produce reports and agencies that produce revenue is backlink quality, content strategy, and knowing which pages actually convert. uSERP engineers all three, and now extends that same authority into AI search platforms where your buyers are increasingly starting their research.

Hey folks, it's your content friend Eric here.

About 5 years into my career, I loved saying no.

I loved flagging all the reasons why a marketing campaign would fail. I loved pointing out that a data report was meaningless because it didn’t have statistical significance. I loved editing things to death. I loved saying that we should slow down and focus on quality rather than quantity. I loved saying we were over capacity and couldn’t take on another project.

Part of this was because I loved feeling smart. Part of this (I learned much later) was due to some undiagnosed anxiety that led to some unhealthy avoidance. Trying and failing wasn’t really an option for me. I preferred to stay comfortable.

This worked fine enough when I worked on bigger teams. I was a productive filter of ideas (from my perspective, at least—who knows how enjoyable I was to work with…).

But once I started working as a solo content marketer at startups and had more ownership, I became an unproductive filter of success.

Here’s what I learned: You don’t get any points for saying no. And you don’t get any points for being right. You only get points when you make shit happen.

I’ve worked hard to force myself into a habit of saying yes more often (and asking better questions before I say no).

What’s the upshot of a big swing here? What’s the worst that could happen if we try? What unproductive thing can we give ourselves permission to stop doing if we take on this new, high-potential thing? If this fails, what positives can we take from it?

Of course, I can’t say yes to everything. I’m a team of one, and I have to protect my capacity. But I’ve learned that nobody has all the answers, and nobody can predict how any of this will go.

The reason I wanted to write this rather public diary entry is that I think there’s a “curse of knowledge” mid-career hump that many content marketers go through.

You’ve kind of seen all there is to see at one or two companies, so it’s tempting for your knowledge to start to solidify instead of staying plastic and open-minded.

Every marketing strategy has reasons not to do it. If you open LinkedIn right now, you will find someone saying why strategy X doesn’t work. And they’ll probably be right to a degree (SEO doesn’t work because… Podcasts don’t work because…). If you internalize more of the ‘cons’ than the ‘pros’, you’ll start saying no to good ideas when you probably shouldn’t.

I’ve seen some really great content marketers go through it when they avoid failure rather than chase success.

I think I’ve achieved a healthy balance now. My boss threw out a big, ambitious project idea at me yesterday, and my instinct was finally to say yes instead of no (even though I did flag that I’d have to drop something else to take it on).

TL;DR: keep an open mind, take the occasional leap of faith, and don’t worry about being the smartest person in the room.

Cheers,

PS. Last week’s newsletter beat the record for most replies I’ve ever received. I’m glad that some other folks are falling back in love with writing thanks to AI.

📧Website analytics with beehiivEmail tools of the past treated newsletters as a one-time send. With beehiiv, every issue lives as a post on your own site with its own analytics, making the newsletter content more evergreen. I've been surprised by how much traffic we’re on the site after just a couple of months. - Alex

Want to try beehiiv? Use SUPERPATH30 for 30% off

📆 Upcoming Superpath Community Events

To get the invitations to our virtual events, join Superpath Pro. You get 30 days free, so you’d be able to attend all these events!

  • Slack AMA (Apr 30): Katie Parrott, Staff Writer & AI Editorial Lead at Every, will answer your questions about their AI-led editorial strategy.

  • Superpath Social (May 14): Meet a bunch of other content marketers in our 1-hour virtual mixer.

  • Change My Mind (May 20): Our monthly open discussion where we debate someone’s hot take.

  • AI Show & Tell (May 21): Three marketers will show off things they’ve built with AI. All past recordings are available in our courses archive.

  • Slack AMA (May 28): Kaleigh Moore, AEO agency owner and former journalist, answers all your burning questions about AEO that ChatGPT never could!

And don't miss our open-to-everyone, in-person events:

Shout out to everyone who attended our Seattle event last week!

🎙 New on Content, Briefly: The Budget Mistake Everyone's Making with GEO with Jeremy Moser

uSERP’s Jeremy Moser talks to 30+ new companies a month and keeps seeing the same flawed logic: teams comparing bottom-of-funnel AI search leads against their entire SEO pipeline—and shifting budget based on a comparison that doesn't hold up.

About 36% of uSERP's own leads self-report as coming from AI search, and even that number is murky once you factor in all the other touchpoints along the way.

In this episode, Alex and Jeremy get into:

  • Why AI search leads and SEO leads aren't actually comparable

  • Why cutting SEO to fund GEO tends to backfire when training data refreshes

  • How ~90% of bottom-of-funnel AI mentions come from third-party sites, not your own

  • Why Jeremy recommends keeping ~70% of your budget in traditional SEO

  • Where content marketers should be investing their time and skills right now

💬 Great Slack Threads This Week

Here are some great questions members asked in Superpath Pro this week:

  • I’ve got a call this week with the CEO of a deep tech company I’ve been freelancing with. What’s actually worked for you when pitching content value to a skeptical exec? Any tips on demonstrating impact early in a role?

  • How do you move your role away from being the person who "writes words? I'm the only person in our company who has content writing and copywriting experience. We have some pretty aggressive growth goals for 2026, and this has led to huge scope creep in requests for things like one-pagers, email sequences, slide decks, and so on. While it's nice to be indispensable, being the company copywriter isn't doing my professional development any favors. Thoughts?

  • I'm looking to be promoted within the next 6 months, and I'm curious: what would you say are the most important duties or responsibilities a manager-level content leader should have?

📙 The Reading List

Here are some thought-provoking articles shared in the Superpath Slack community this week:

🆓 Get a free 30-day trial of Superpath Pro

Superpath Pro is our paid community membership. On your free trial, you'll get access to:

  • A private Slack community with 400+ in-house and freelance content marketers

  • Monthly 1:1 peer networking calls

  • Monthly group events with breakout sessions

  • Monthly AI Show & Tell workshops

  • Graduate-level content courses

  • Niche channels and events for freelancers, content leaders, and more

"Superpath is hands down the best community for content marketers. It's one of the only communities I log in to daily because there's so much to learn from the conversations. Being a fly on the wall is itself worth the price of admission. Don't think twice about joining Superpath—it's a serious career accelerant."

— Tanaaz Khan, Content Strategist

Keep reading